Authored by Shree Kargutkar, Portfolio Manager, Sprott Asset Management LP
This is Part 2 in our series focused on platinum. Here we explore the unique supply-demand fundamentals that support our bullish outlook on platinum. Part 1 serves as a primer on platinum.
If you’ve been scratching your head over the divergence in price between platinum and palladium, you’re not alone. Although we have favored palladium over platinum since 2012, we never expected palladium ($1,135) to be priced at a premium to platinum ($832), or for platinum to be trading at a nearly $400/oz discount to gold ($1,234)1. The primary culprit for platinum’s continued price weakness has been the negative impact of the diesel emissions scandal ("dieselgate"), as we discussed in Part 1.
At the time of this writing, you could purchase approximately three ounces of platinum for two ounces of gold. Platinum is trading well under the 1.0 platinum-to-gold ratio that is considered the historical norm, and which we have not seen since 2015. The current ratio of 0.67:1.0 means platinum is currently a bargain: an ounce of platinum is selling at 67% the price of an ounce of gold.
Platinum’s low price is not a reflection of lack of demand. As we explored in Part 1, platinum is not only an important investment asset, it is used in multiple industries and overall demand remains robust. Platinum supply continues to remain tight, and demand has outstripped supply in five of the past six years. With platinum supply under great pressure, we think that platinum has become too cheap to ignore.
Figure 1: Platinum vs. Gold and Palladium Prices Since 2000
Source: Bloomberg. XPT (black line/shaded blue) represents platinum; XAU (gold line) represents gold; XPD (dark blue line) represents palladium. Data as of 10/23/2018.
We have not been alone in observing the imbalance of supply and demand in platinum over the past six years. The size of above ground platinum stockpiles plugging the supply demand hole has been a hot topic at many commodity-focused events in recent years. While there has been plenty of speculation, very little data had been previously available, as not much analysis has been done on this issue. Unsurprisingly, the combination of rumor-mongering and the metaphorical broken telephone have a habit of making a mountain out of a molehill. The rumored estimate of the mysterious above-ground saleable platinum kept growing from 2012 into 2016. What was initially thought to be a 6 million ounce stockpile in 2012 grew to 10 million ounces in 2017 based on one industry anecdote.
How else could platinum prices continue to sharply decline between 2012 and 2017 when industry watchers such as World Platinum Investment Council (WPIC)and Johnson Matthey (JM) continued to report deficits as large as 720,000 ounces? We had heard similar rumors holding back the price of palladium in the early part of the decade. Russia had been selling its palladium stockpile to plug the deficit in the market at that time and the size of the Russian stock was prone to great exaggeration. As the Russian stockpile reached low levels, in late 2016 based on the sales we tracked through Switzerland, the price of palladium began appreciating rapidly as demand was outstripping supply. Thanks to the research done by the WPIC we now have a reasonable answer to the above-ground stock of saleable platinum. As Figure 2 shows, the above-ground stockpile is close to being exhausted.
Figure 2: Platinum Supply vs. Price (1976-2016)
Source: World Platinum Investment Council.
Several astute, plugged-in investors have been aware of the issues plaguing platinum mines in South Africa, which account for almost 75% of global platinum production. Platinum bearing ores in South Africa are primarily mined from the Merensky Reef and the upper group 2 (UG-2) ore bodies in the Bushveld Igneous Complex (BIC). Both the Merensky and UG-2 ore bodies are too narrow to be mined using mechanized mining equipment. An immense amount of human labor is required to extract these ores. The mines have never had a great track record of safety due to the combination of poor infrastructure and weak enforcement of safety protocols. It is not uncommon to have workers who may be intoxicated, who may have drugs in their system or who may be sick, working underground in 110F+ heat. It comes as no surprise that with every injury or death, workers demand higher wages for risking life and limb.
Strikes occur annually and mine output is often affected. Every year, labor unions make outrageous demands and typically settle for a high single-digit wage increase. There have been years when strikes have persisted far longer than expected. 2014 was a particularly tough year, which saw large-scale strikes which lasted for five months. That year, South Africa’s platinum production contracted 16% versus 2013. The real impact of wage increases have partially been offset by inflation in South Africa.
As the price of platinum has faltered over the better part of the decade, and wages have increased, platinum miners have had to make some tough financial decisions. Investments needed to sustain output have declined, as have investments to increase output. Simply put, platinum miners are unprepared for an increase in demand. Equity investors in South Africa’s platinum sector have taken it on the chin. Previously high-flying platinum mining companies such as Lonmin, which accounts for almost 17% of South Africa’s platinum output have seen their share prices decline by 99% over the past five years. It is easy to understand why investors have been turned away from this space.
Anyone reading about the platinum mining industry in South Africa will learn that the supply of platinum is declining. Production has slowly dropped since peaking in 2006, however, the declines have been quite modest. Sociopolitical factors, strong palladium prices and South African Rand weakness are the three key factors at play here and they deserve to be examined.
Figure 3: South African Platinum Supply has Declined (‘000 oz; 2007-Present)
Source: Bloomberg. Johnson Matthey.
South Africa’s rise to becoming Africa’s wealthiest economy has been driven by its rich history of mining. Gold, diamonds, platinum and coal have all been mined in South Africa for decades, which in turn has driven its economic development. However, there still exists a vast divide between the wealthy and the poor today.
While there is a growing number of educated, highly skilled blacks in South Africa, the impact of Apartheid which began in 1948 and ended in 1995 continues to be felt today. The economic mishandling under Jacob Zuma has resulted in high inflation, high levels of violent crime and high unemployment. The latter is of particular concern because with today’s unemployment level hovering around 27% and almost 500,000 South Africans employed by the mining sector, the social cost of laying off workers is astronomical.
Figure 4: South Africa’s Rising Unemployment Rate (2008-2018)
According to the Minerals Council of South Africa, each worker employed in a South African mine has nine dependents. As recently as 2012, the government has gone so far as to threaten to take away the mining licenses of companies deemed to be “misrepresenting their intentions.” This threat came after Anglo American Platinum (Amplats), one of the world’s largest mining companies, submitted a proposal to mothball portions of its Rustenburg operations at the cost of 14,000 jobs.
Uneconomic mines, which would be closed in most countries, continue to be operated in South Africa and will likely continue to do so until the operating companies go bankrupt, or until the unemployment rate improves.
Rising Palladium and Rhodium Prices Provide Support
Strong palladium prices have been a godsend to South African platinum miners. Like many other metals, platinum occurs in the ground in combination with palladium, rhodium and gold. This basket of precious metals is mined as a single unit out of the ground in South Africa and across the world.
South African mines are the only mines known to produce a higher content of platinum versus palladium, whereas, virtually all other known ore bodies have a higher concentration of palladium over platinum. On a rather simplistic basis, a single unit of ore in South African mines contains approximately 58% platinum, 32% palladium, 8% rhodium and 2% gold by volume. This means that a drop in platinum can be offset if the price of palladium or rhodium rises sufficiently. Platinum prices have declined by almost 40% in the past five years, while the price of gold has held steady. Palladium has gained 35%. Rhodium has appreciated by a whopping 225% in the same period. As platinum prices have collapsed by 40% over the past five years, the impact has been buffered by rising palladium and rhodium prices. The Platinum Group Metals (PGM) basket price has declined by under 20% in the same period.
Figure 5: PGM Basket Prices in USD (10/2013-10/2018)
Source: Bloomberg. Data as of 10/23/2018.
Thus far, we have been analyzing the data through the lens of the U.S. dollar. At the ground level, a majority of the costs are measured in South Africa’s local currency, the Rand. The South African economy remains weak and has long been plagued by the twin ravages of high unemployment and high inflation, which has naturally led to a decline in the Rand. In the past five years alone, the Rand has lost nearly 25% of its value to the U.S. Dollar.
Figure 6: The South African Rand Remains Weak vs. U.S. Dollar (2013-2018)
The Rand’s weakness has been a small blessing for South African miners, but this is not saying much given their shockingly bad share price performance. The miners’ largest cost is labor, which accounts for about 60% of total expenses. Due to the drop in the Rand, even with platinum dropping 40% in USD terms, the revenues earned by the miners have increased by more than 10% per unit of volume over the past five years.
Figure 7: PGM Basket Prices in Rand Terms
Unfortunately, the small problems in the platinum mining space have become large problems over time. Labor costs continue to increase at a faster rate than the Rand has weakened. Access to electricity has remained challenging. The socioeconomic situation in South Africa has continued to deteriorate. Investments to sustain mine production have been declining. The balance sheets of virtually all African PGM miners, except for Amplats, are stretched to the point of breaking. Companies such as Lonmin, which is unable to operate on its own, are being absorbed into other entities. According to our research, almost 50% of platinum mining in South Africa and neighboring Zimbabwe is now uneconomic.
In 2020, JP Morgan estimates that 55% of the PGM miners will be uneconomic at the current PGM basket price. Unless platinum prices rise materially, 1.7 million ounces of platinum supply, almost 30% of the global mine supply is at a threat of being turned off.
With above-ground stocks close to depletion and a majority of mined supply at uneconomic levels, we can only reach one conclusion: Platinum is too cheap to ignore.
|1||Spot platinum and palladium prices are as of 10/23/2018.|
This content is intended solely for the use of Sprott Asset Management USA, Inc. for use with investors and interested parties. Investments, commentary and statements are unique and may not be reflective of investments and commentary in other strategies managed by Sprott Asset Management USA, Inc., Sprott Asset Management LP, Sprott Inc., or any other Sprott entity or affiliate. Opinions expressed in this presentation are those of the presenter and may vary widely from opinions of other Sprott affiliated Portfolio Managers or investment professionals.
This content may not be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without acknowledgment that it was produced by Sprott Asset Management LP and a reference to sprott.com. The opinions, estimates and projections (“information”) contained within this content are solely those of Sprott Asset Management LP (“SAM LP”) and are subject to change without notice. SAM LP makes every effort to ensure that the information has been derived from sources believed to be reliable and accurate. However, SAM LP assumes no responsibility for any losses or damages, whether direct or indirect, which arise out of the use of this information. SAM LP is not under any obligation to update or keep current the information contained herein. The information should not be regarded by recipients as a substitute for the exercise of their own judgment. Please contact your own personal advisor on your particular circumstances. Views expressed regarding a particular company, security, industry or market sector should not be considered an indication of trading intent of any investment funds managed by Sprott Asset Management LP. These views are not to be considered as investment advice nor should they be considered a recommendation to buy or sell. SAM LP and/or its affiliates may collectively beneficially own/control 1% or more of any class of the equity securities of the issuers mentioned in this report. SAM LP and/or its affiliates may hold short position in any class of the equity securities of the issuers mentioned in this report. During the preceding 12 months, SAM LP and/or its affiliates may have received remuneration other than normal course investment advisory or trade execution services from the issuers mentioned in this report.
SAM LP is the investment manager to the Sprott Physical Bullion Trusts (the “Trusts”). Important information about the Trusts, including the investment objectives and strategies, purchase options, applicable management fees, and expenses, is contained in the prospectus. Please read the document carefully before investing. Investment funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated. This communication does not constitute an offer to sell or solicitation to purchase securities of the Trusts.
The risks associated with investing in a Trust depend on the securities and assets in which the Trust invests, based upon the Trust’s particular objectives. There is no assurance that any Trust will achieve its investment objective, and its net asset value, yield and investment return will fluctuate from time to time with market conditions. There is no guarantee that the full amount of your original investment in a Trust will be returned to you. The Trusts are not insured by the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation or any other government deposit insurer. Please read a Trust’s prospectus before investing.
The information contained herein does not constitute an offer or solicitation to anyone in the United States or in any other jurisdiction in which such an offer or solicitation is not authorized or to any person to whom it is unlawful to make such an offer or solicitation. Prospective investors who are not resident in Canada or the United States should contact their financial advisor to determine whether securities of the Funds may be lawfully sold in their jurisdiction.
The information provided is general in nature and is provided with the understanding that it may not be relied upon as, nor considered to be, the rendering or tax, legal, accounting or professional advice. Readers should consult with their own accountants and/or lawyers for advice on the specific circumstances before taking any action.
You are now leaving sprottus.com and entering a linked website.Continue
You are now leaving Sprott.com and entering a linked website. Sprott has partnered with ALPS in offering Sprott ETFs. For fact sheets, marketing materials, prospectuses, performance, expense information and other details about the ETFs, you will be directed to the ALPS/Sprott website at SprottETFs.com.Continue to Sprott Exchange Traded Funds
You are now leaving Sprott.com and entering a linked website. Sprott Asset Management is a sub-advisor for several mutual funds on behalf of Ninepoint Partners. For details on these funds, you will be directed to the Ninepoint Partners website at ninepoint.com.Continue to Ninepoint Partners